Why Persona 6 Should not Observe the Motion RPG Development
Motion RPGs appear to be doing nicely for themselves these days. Except for latest hits grounded within the style, like Elden Ring and Horizon Forbidden West, well-established turn-based IPs from Sq. Enix appear to be leaning into motion parts as nicely. Remaining Fantasy 16 has an enormous emphasis on motion, and it is attainable that Dragon Quest 12: The Flames of Destiny will contain some motion parts in its deliberate fight changes. Whereas this style is clearly robust proper now, that does not imply Persona 6 wants to affix it. Quite the opposite, Atlus can be higher off sticking to its turn-based roots.
Persona and turn-based fight go hand in hand. Not solely does the Persona franchise have its personal wealthy historical past of turn-based fight stretching again to the Nineties, but it surely inherits a legacy from its dad or mum franchise Shin Megami Tensei, which continues to affect it to today. Atlus has lengthy confirmed that it loves sticking to custom, so the chances of an motion RPG change most likely aren’t excessive, however the style’s success might make it tempting nonetheless. Ideally Persona 6 will as an alternative double down on the IP’s turn-based conventions and innovate on what it is aware of greatest, moderately than stepping out into one thing completely completely different.
Persona 6 Ought to Respect Its Flip-Based mostly Heritage
One main cause that Persona 6 should not turn out to be an motion RPG is its latest worldwide breakthrough. Whereas Persona had its worldwide followers earlier than, the Persona 5 suite of video games has vastly elevated the dimensions of the fanbase. It might be moderately jarring if all these gamers newly fell in love with a turn-based JRPG collection, solely to see it all of the sudden shift into an motion franchise. That dissonance might flip some latest followers away. Persona has established a transparent identification with new followers that is value preserving.
An motion flip might additionally hamper Persona‘s spinoff potential. The musou-style sport Persona 5 Strikers showcased that Persona can positively work in an action-oriented gameplay loop, offering thrilling hack-and-slash encounters whereas preserving the important thing fantasy of wielding Persona powers strategically. Strikers has loads of potential as a brand new spinoff collection, becoming a member of the ranks of Persona Enviornment and the Persona dancing video games, but when the entire IP grew to become action-based, then Strikers would really feel somewhat out of date. Maintaining the principle video games turn-based would go away the door open to extra musou titles that capitalize on Persona 5 Strikers‘ success.
Maybe the best cause, nevertheless, is just that becoming a member of the motion RPG development would fail to make Persona 6 stand out. Even with the energy of the Persona model, taking an motion RPG flip now can be far too apparent an imitation of Remaining Fantasy‘s route to really feel particular or inventive. There’s not a lot sense in Atlus shifting away from its space of experience, solely to hop on a bandwagon. In truth, Persona would possibly truly compete higher with its JRPG friends if it sticks to its conventions and gives the very best high quality turn-based play it could muster, because it’d give followers of the style someplace apparent and dependable to show if the AAA motion RPG market would not swimsuit their tastes.
None of that is to say that the Persona fight system is ideal. Persona 5 and Persona 5 Royal are noticeably simpler video games than the last few generations, regardless of having extra difficult fight techniques; preset dungeon designs and essential mechanics like Persona 5‘s Baton Move give gamers way more management over the sport loop than earlier than. Ideally Persona 6 will acknowledge this and discover methods to show up the warmth whereas preserving the video games accessible, probably by preserving Persona 5 Royal‘s player-side techniques in place and specializing in producing more durable enemy designs. Atlus has the know-how to maintain Persona‘s conventional fight contemporary, so hopefully it would not really feel too tempted by the latest success of Persona‘s motion RPG cousins.
Persona 6 is in improvement.
